Skip to main content

Hiring for Childcare Is a Huge Struggle in the United States

Practice, service, or business of caring for other people’s children

Hiring for Childcare Is a Huge Struggle in the United States

Parents struggle to obtain care, and the remaining employees are under growing stress as childcare facilities throughout the nation struggle to hire and keep personnel due to a lack of suitable employment. 

Since losing a third of its personnel at the start of the epidemic, the childcare sector has had a delayed and uneven job recovery. It is now reversing course. Economists and policy experts warn that the broader labor market may suffer if this business continues to struggle. 

This is because working parents scurry to find childcare due to workforce cutbacks, persistent issues with low pay, and patchy employee benefits. The daycare sector was already struggling to make ends meet before the epidemic, and it is now truly at its breaking point. 

Parents’ hours worked decreased due to interruptions to school and childcare facilities. The labor supply and the careers of working parents may be negatively impacted for a long time by disruptions to childcare operations.

The Biggest Challenges

Before the epidemic, it was difficult to obtain aid when you needed it, and that problem still exists today. Various issues, including poor wages, have led to a labor crisis. Longtime caregivers have received little pay and insufficient benefits, such as health insurance. 

US daycare employees receive an hourly wage of $13.51 on average. $27.31 per hour is over half of what the typical US worker earns. This frequently entails that childcare providers cannot support their families or themselves.

This, in turn, raises the possibility of towns and cities developing into childcare deserts, lowering the quality of care and increasing job turnover rates. It’s one of the lowest-paid occupations in the nation and requires a lot of physical, mental, and emotional labor. 

Childcare has fallen behind as the US employment market recovers from the coronavirus outbreak. The industry has lost around 9.7% of its workers compared to pre-pandemic levels. The lack of personnel has reduced the number of children who can get care. 

A stronger economy would result from higher compensation since it would promote employee satisfaction and financial security for workers. As a substitute, educators frequently choose better-paying, less demanding employment in retail and restaurants.

The Catch-22

However, pay increases might lead to a Catch-22 situation. It may increase daycare prices, which are currently among the highest for American families. Parental payment is the main funding source for early childhood centers, as opposed to public K–12 schools, which are supported by tax revenue. 

Public help may be provided to them, although it varies greatly between states and jurisdictions. When compared to other industrialized countries, the US makes an appallingly little contribution to early childhood education and care. 

Therefore, the majority of those costs must be borne by parents. The Biden administration has called for increasing funding for childcare in its Build Back Better plan, particularly through subsidies to ensure that low- and middle-income families don’t spend more than 7% of their income on childcare and through universal preschool. 

But the success of those initiatives is far from clear. Publicly financed K–12 institutions recruit many instructors because they frequently provide greater pay, vacation time, and other perks. 

According to center directors, daycares may see a brain drain as more experienced employees depart. While some childcare facilities have sought to keep employees by raising salaries and benefits, doing so is challenging due to their limited financial means.

A Dying Industry

Parents have felt the pinch as alternatives for care have grown increasingly constrained due to staffing constraints. This hurts the industry and prevents employees who are responsible for providing care, especially mothers, from participating fully in the labor market. 

This hurts the industry and prevents employees who are responsible for providing care, especially mothers, from participating fully in the labor market. Many low-wage workers are reevaluating their career choices and looking for better positions from their employers and the labor market amid a tight labor market that has given low-wage workers more leverage. 

The childcare workforce, in particular, has shown that workers are not planning to continue in the field without significantly improving the quality of jobs, including improved compensation. Some parents—most likely mothers—may have to cut back on their working hours or leave the workforce altogether if they struggle to secure childcare. 

Additionally, for early childhood educators who stay in the field, added obligations may result in greater stress levels, decreased productivity, or increased employee departures. Notably, it has long been known that higher-quality occupations are linked to lower employee turnover and increased productivity, both of which are advantageous to businesses.

The Solution

Without financing from the general people and action, we cannot resolve this issue. It is analogous to attempting to pay for a public education system using parent fees. Given that many working-class parents already struggle to make funds meet, increasing tuition is just not an option. 

More government participation is the answer. With guarantees of greater pay and improved working conditions for the workers, this might include universal pre-K, financial assistance for service providers, and family subsidies. There is no reason why states and towns can’t undertake the same efforts as the federal government, albeit that may occur.

Register to Vote